What is Good Mileage for a Used Car: The Complete Guide

Good Mileage for a Used Car

So you’re in the market for a used car, huh? Let me guess – one of your first questions is about the mileage. And why wouldn’t it be? That little number on the odometer can make or break your decision faster than you can say “pre-owned vehicle.”

But here’s the thing about car mileage – it’s not as straightforward as most people think. Sure, lower numbers generally seem better, but is a car with 50,000 miles always a better buy than one with 100,000? Not necessarily! Mileage is just one piece of a much larger puzzle.

In this guide, we’re going to break down everything you need to know about used car mileage – from what numbers should raise eyebrows to which ones might actually represent a hidden gem. By the time you finish reading, you’ll walk onto that car lot armed with knowledge that could save you thousands of dollars and countless headaches.

The Truth About Car Mileage Benchmarks

Remember when hitting 100,000 miles meant your car was basically on life support? Those days are long gone, my friend.

According to data from IHS Markit, the average age of vehicles on U.S. roads hit a record high of 12.2 years in 2023. That’s not just cars sitting in garages either – we’re talking about vehicles that are still cruising down highways every day!

“But what about that magical 100,000-mile threshold I’ve always heard about?” I hear you asking.

Well, that myth needs to be tossed in the junkyard where it belongs. Modern vehicles are engineered to last far longer, with many easily surpassing 200,000 miles when properly maintained. A 2022 Consumer Reports study found that nearly 30% of Toyota and Honda owners reported their vehicles lasting beyond 200,000 miles without major repairs.

The truth is, good mileage for a used car isn’t a one-size-fits-all number. It varies dramatically based on:

  • Vehicle type and class – A heavy-duty truck built for hauling is designed differently than a compact commuter car
  • Manufacturer reliability ratings – Some brands simply build engines that last longer (we’ll get into specifics later)
  • Maintenance history – A well-cared-for car with higher mileage often trumps a neglected low-mileage vehicle
  • Driving conditions – Highway miles are generally easier on a vehicle than stop-and-go city driving

Think of good mileage like a healthy weight – it depends entirely on the individual and a host of other factors!

Mileage Guidelines by Vehicle Type

Not all vehicles age the same way. Just like different dog breeds have different lifespans, vehicle categories have their own mileage expectations. Let’s break it down:

Sedans and Compact Cars

These everyday champions are typically designed for efficiency and commuting. For sedans and compact cars, good mileage benchmarks look something like this:

  • Excellent: Under 50,000 miles
  • Good: 50,000-100,000 miles
  • Average: 100,000-150,000 miles
  • High: Over 150,000 miles

But don’t let “high” scare you! Many compact cars and sedans from reliable manufacturers like Toyota, Honda, and Mazda regularly surpass 200,000 miles. According to a study by iSeeCars, the Toyota Avalon and Honda Accord were among the top 10 vehicles most likely to reach 200,000+ miles.

SUVs and Crossovers

These family-friendly vehicles often pack more robust engineering:

  • Excellent: Under 60,000 miles
  • Good: 60,000-120,000 miles
  • Average: 120,000-180,000 miles
  • High: Over 180,000 miles

SUVs typically have stronger frames and powertrains built for versatility. The Toyota Land Cruiser, Toyota Sequoia, and Chevrolet Suburban have some of the highest longevity ratings, with many examples surpassing 300,000 miles according to a 2023 report from iSeeCars.

Trucks

These workhorses are literally built to take a beating:

  • Excellent: Under 75,000 miles
  • Good: 75,000-150,000 miles
  • Average: 150,000-200,000 miles
  • High: Over 200,000 miles

Have you ever wondered why trucks command higher prices even with more miles? It’s because their heavy-duty components are designed for extended use. The Ford F-150, Toyota Tundra, and Chevrolet Silverado regularly rank among vehicles most likely to surpass 200,000 miles. A 2022 survey by Autolist found that 28% of truck owners reported driving their vehicles beyond 250,000 miles!

Luxury Vehicles

Here’s where things get tricky. Luxury cars often have more complex systems:

  • Excellent: Under 40,000 miles
  • Good: 40,000-80,000 miles
  • Average: 80,000-120,000 miles
  • High: Over 120,000 miles

The lower thresholds aren’t because luxury vehicles are built poorly – quite the opposite! But their advanced technologies and performance components often require more meticulous maintenance. When buying a used luxury vehicle, maintenance history becomes even more critical than the actual mileage. A Lexus with 130,000 miles and complete dealer service records might be a better buy than a BMW with 70,000 miles and spotty maintenance.

Why Age vs. Mileage Matters More

Have you ever noticed how car insurance forms ask for both your vehicle’s year and its mileage? There’s a good reason for that!

The relationship between a car’s age and its mileage tells you far more than either number alone. The average driver puts about 13,500 miles on their car annually, according to the Federal Highway Administration. This means a 5-year-old car would ideally have around 67,500 miles.

So what happens when these numbers don’t align? Let’s explore:

The High-Mileage Newer Car

Imagine finding a 3-year-old car with 75,000 miles. That’s about 25,000 miles per year – well above average. Does this make it a bad buy?

Not necessarily! Higher annual mileage often indicates highway driving. Highway miles put less strain on the vehicle compared to city driving with its constant stopping and starting. Components like the brakes, transmission, and engine actually experience less wear and tear on highways despite covering more distance.

A 2021 study published in the Journal of Transport & Health found that vehicles primarily driven on highways had approximately 23% less wear on key mechanical systems than equivalent vehicles used mainly for city driving.

The Time Capsule: Low-Mileage Older Cars

What about that 12-year-old car with only 45,000 miles? Sounds like a dream, right?

Surprisingly, these “time capsule” vehicles can sometimes be mechanical nightmares. Cars are designed to be driven regularly. When they sit unused for long periods, several problems can develop:

  • Rubber components (belts, hoses, seals) dry out and crack
  • Fluids break down and become less effective
  • Moisture accumulates in fuel and other systems
  • Batteries deteriorate and electrical systems develop issues

According to data from AAA, vehicles driven less than 5,000 miles annually were twice as likely to develop fluid leaks and three times more likely to have battery failures compared to regularly driven vehicles.

The sweet spot? A vehicle with slightly below-average annual mileage (around 10,000-12,000 miles per year) typically represents the best of both worlds – enough use to keep everything functioning properly but not so much as to accelerate wear.

Beyond the Odometer: Critical Factors

Good Mileage for a Used Car

If you’ve stuck with me this far, you’re probably thinking, “Okay, so good mileage for a used car depends on many factors.” And you’d be absolutely right! Now let’s dig into those other factors that can make or break your used car purchase.

Maintenance History: The Golden Ticket

Would you rather buy a car with 120,000 well-maintained miles or 60,000 neglected ones? If you chose the first option, congratulations – you’re thinking like a mechanic!

A complete maintenance history is like a vehicle’s medical record. It tells you how well the previous owner(s) cared for the car and whether they addressed issues promptly or let small problems grow into big ones.

According to a 2022 CarFax report, vehicles with documented regular maintenance histories retained approximately 15-25% more value than those without. Even more telling, they experienced 40% fewer major mechanical failures within the first year after purchase.

Look for:

  • Regular oil changes (typically every 5,000-7,500 miles)
  • Timely replacement of wear items (brakes, tires, batteries)
  • Completion of manufacturer-recommended service intervals
  • Records of addressing recalls and technical service bulletins

Pro tip: A vehicle with higher mileage and complete dealer service records often represents better value than a lower-mileage car with spotty or missing maintenance history.

The Owner Factor: One vs. Many

Have you ever wondered why dealerships highlight “one-owner” vehicles? There’s solid reasoning behind it.

Multiple owners typically mean:

  • Different driving habits
  • Varying maintenance approaches
  • Potential for missed service intervals during transitions
  • Higher likelihood of unreported accidents or issues

A 2023 analysis by Edmunds found that single-owner vehicles commanded prices approximately 5-8% higher than equivalent multiple-owner vehicles, even with similar mileage and condition.

Highway vs. City Miles: Not All Mileage Is Created Equal

We touched on this earlier, but it bears repeating – how a car was driven matters as much as how far.

Highway driving typically means:

  • Steady speeds with fewer temperature fluctuations in the engine
  • Less wear on brakes and transmission
  • Fewer pothole impacts and suspension stress
  • More complete combustion and cleaner engine operation

City driving typically means:

  • Frequent stops and starts that stress the drivetrain
  • More wear on brakes and transmission components
  • More idling time, which can lead to carbon buildup
  • Shorter trips where the engine doesn’t reach optimal temperature

According to research from CarEdge.com, vehicles primarily driven on highways typically last 20-30% longer before requiring major repairs compared to those used mainly for city driving.

Climate and Geography: The Hidden Influencers

Where a car has spent its life can tell you a lot about potential issues:

  • Salt Belt States: Vehicles from snowy regions where roads are salted (Northeast, Midwest) often experience more undercarriage rust. A 5-year-old car from Minnesota might have more corrosion than a 10-year-old car from Arizona.
  • Extreme Heat Regions: Cars from places like Arizona and Nevada often have deteriorated rubber components and faded interiors, but typically less rust.
  • Coastal Areas: Proximity to salt air can accelerate corrosion.
  • Mountainous Regions: More strain on transmissions and brakes from hill climbing.

A 2021 study by Kelley Blue Book found that identical vehicle models had a 15-20% difference in lifespan based solely on geographic location, with vehicles in moderate climates typically lasting longer. Want to know more, visit our website….

Red Flags When Evaluating Used Car Mileage

Let’s talk about some serious warning signs that should make you think twice – no matter how “good” the mileage might seem at first glance.

Odometer Discrepancies: When Numbers Lie

Ever had that gut feeling something just doesn’t add up? Trust it when looking at car mileage.

According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), over 450,000 vehicles are sold annually with fraudulent odometer readings, costing buyers more than $1 billion each year. Yikes!

Here’s how to spot potential odometer fraud:

  • Check for consistency across documents: Compare the mileage on the title, service records, and vehicle history reports. Even small discrepancies deserve investigation.
  • Look for physical evidence: Excessive wear on pedals, the steering wheel, or driver’s seat that doesn’t match low mileage is a major red flag.
  • Inspect the odometer itself: Digital odometers with misaligned numbers or ones that stick might have been tampered with.

Pro tip: If buying from a private seller, ask to see maintenance records with mileage noted. A 2022 study by Carfax found that vehicles with odometer rollbacks were typically listed for 15-25% above their actual market value!

Signs of Premature Wear: When the Car Ages Faster Than Its Miles

Have you ever met someone who looked way older than their actual age? Cars can be like that too.

A vehicle with good mileage for a used car should show wear consistent with its odometer reading. Here are signs that something’s off:

  • Heavily worn pedals or driver’s seat with under 50,000 miles
  • Significant engine or transmission issues before reaching average lifespan milestones
  • Extensive body rust or paint fading that suggests much more age/use
  • Electrical problems typically associated with much older vehicles

According to a 2023 Consumer Reports reliability survey, premature wear issues were reported in about 17% of used car purchases, with buyers citing these problems as their biggest regrets.

Maintenance Gaps: The Silent Killers

Did you know that skipping just a few oil changes can cut an engine’s lifespan by up to 30%? That’s according to research from the Car Care Council.

When evaluating good mileage for a used car, maintenance history gaps can completely change the equation. Be especially wary of:

  • Missing oil changes: Especially concerning if gaps exceed 10,000 miles
  • Skipped timing belt replacements: These are typically scheduled between 60,000-100,000 miles depending on the vehicle
  • Ignored transmission services: These should generally occur every 30,000-60,000 miles
  • Neglected cooling system flushes: Usually needed every 60,000 miles

A 2023 study published in the Journal of Automotive Engineering found that vehicles with consistent maintenance histories lasted an average of 22% longer than those with spotted service records – even when the vehicles started with identical mileage!

How to Evaluate a High-Mileage Vehicle

So your dream car has higher mileage than you’d hoped. Don’t walk away just yet! High-mileage doesn’t automatically mean “bad purchase” if you know what to look for.

Pre-Purchase Inspection Checklist: Your Best $150 Investment

Would you spend $150 to potentially save $2,000? That’s essentially what a good pre-purchase inspection offers, especially for higher-mileage vehicles.

According to data from AAA, the average pre-purchase inspection costs between $100-200 but can identify issues that might cost 10-20 times that amount to fix later.

Here’s what a thorough inspection should include for any vehicle, but especially one with good mileage for a used car that’s on the higher end:

  • Compression test: Reveals the engine’s internal health
  • Transmission diagnostic: Identifies early warning signs of transmission issues
  • Electrical system evaluation: Tests battery, alternator, and overall electrical health
  • Undercarriage inspection: Checks for rust, leaks, and structural issues
  • Suspension and steering assessment: Identifies worn components
  • Emissions system verification: Ensures all sensors and catalytic converters work properly

Key Components to Check at Different Mileage Intervals

Every vehicle has predictable wear points based on mileage. Here’s what should have been replaced or serviced at common mileage milestones:

50,000-75,000 Miles:

  • Brake pads and possibly rotors
  • Transmission fluid change
  • Coolant system flush
  • Full tune-up including spark plugs

75,000-100,000 Miles:

  • Timing belt/chain (on most vehicles)
  • Water pump (often done with timing belt)
  • Power steering fluid flush
  • Suspension components inspection

100,000-150,000 Miles:

  • Major cooling system components
  • Transmission service or rebuild
  • Suspension overhaul
  • Fuel system cleaning

According to RepairPal’s 2023 reliability data, vehicles that had these services performed on schedule experienced 60% fewer major mechanical failures in the subsequent 20,000 miles compared to vehicles that missed these service intervals.

When a High-Mileage Car Can Be a Better Deal

Ready for a hot take? Sometimes, higher mileage vehicles are actually BETTER buys! Crazy, right?

Consider this: A J.D. Power study found that vehicles with 100,000+ miles that had undergone major component replacements (timing chains, water pumps, etc.) often lasted another 100,000 miles with minimal issues.

High-mileage vehicles can be great deals when:

  • They’ve recently had major services completed
  • Most wear components have already been replaced
  • The price reflects a steep depreciation curve
  • They’ve been used primarily for highway driving

One of my favorite strategies is looking for vehicles just past major maintenance milestones. A car with 110,000 miles that just had its timing belt, water pump, and major services done might be a better value than one with 85,000 miles approaching those same expensive services.

Manufacturer-Specific Considerations

Not all car brands are created equal when it comes to longevity. Understanding manufacturer tendencies can completely redefine what good mileage for a used car means for specific makes and models.

Brands Known for Longevity: The Distance Champions

Some manufacturers simply build cars that last longer. According to iSeeCars’ 2023 study analyzing over 2 million used vehicles, these brands had the highest percentage of vehicles exceeding 200,000 miles:

  1. Toyota: 2.3% of all Toyota vehicles reached 200,000+ miles
  2. Honda: 1.9% of all Honda vehicles reached 200,000+ miles
  3. GMC: 1.8% of all GMC vehicles reached 200,000+ miles
  4. Chevrolet: 1.6% of all Chevrolet vehicles reached 200,000+ miles
  5. Ford: 1.5% of all Ford vehicles reached 200,000+ miles

For these brands, “good mileage for a used car” might need adjustment upward. A Toyota with 120,000 miles might have the same remaining lifespan as another manufacturer’s vehicle with just 80,000 miles.

My two cents? Japanese brands generally excel at building engines and transmissions that last, while American brands tend to make durable body structures and electrical systems. Each has their strengths!

Models That Typically Exceed Mileage Expectations

Certain specific models consistently outperform even their own brand’s averages. According to Consumer Reports’ 2023 reliability data and verified owner reports, these vehicles regularly exceed 250,000 miles with proper maintenance:

  • Toyota Land Cruiser: The undisputed champion, with many exceeding 300,000 miles
  • Honda Civic: Particularly the 2006-2011 generations
  • Toyota Camry: Especially the 2002-2006 four-cylinder models
  • Lexus ES: Combining luxury with Toyota reliability
  • Ford F-150: Particularly with the 5.0L V8 engine
  • Subaru Outback: With consistent head gasket maintenance
  • Toyota Tacoma: The small truck reliability king
  • Honda Accord: Bulletproof with the 4-cylinder engine

For these specific models, you can often add 25-30% to what would normally be considered “good mileage” for their vehicle class.

Vehicles to Approach with Caution at Higher Mileages

On the flip side, some vehicles tend to develop significant issues as they accumulate miles. Based on data from RepairPal and extended warranty claims analyzed by Endurance in 2023, these vehicles often require more scrutiny at higher mileages:

  • BMW 3-Series (particularly 2006-2013): Prone to oil leaks and electrical issues after 80,000 miles
  • Nissan Altima (2013-2016): Transmission concerns often appearing around 100,000 miles
  • Range Rover (all years): Significant electrical and air suspension issues typically beginning around 70,000 miles
  • Volkswagen Jetta (2009-2015): Timing chain tensioner failures commonly reported between 80,000-120,000 miles
  • Chrysler 200: Transmission concerns typically appearing around 90,000 miles

For these vehicles, good mileage for a used car might need to be adjusted downward by 20-30% compared to class averages.

My personal take? Every manufacturer has their hits and misses. Research the specific model year you’re considering, not just the brand reputation.

Making the Decision: Putting Mileage in Context

Good Mileage for a Used Car

We’ve covered a lot of ground (pun intended!), but now comes the million-dollar question: How do you actually make a smart decision about good mileage for a used car when you’re staring at real options?

Price vs. Mileage Evaluation Strategy

Let’s be honest – most of us have a budget, and that budget is often the deciding factor. The trick is maximizing value within that budget.

According to Edmunds’ 2023 used car marketplace data, vehicles lose approximately:

  • 20-30% of their value in the first year
  • 15-20% in the second year
  • 12-15% in the third year
  • 10-12% in the fourth year
  • 8-10% in the fifth year

After that, depreciation slows significantly, with annual depreciation averaging 5-8% in years 5-10.

So how do you use this information? By finding the sweet spot where depreciation has already occurred but plenty of useful life remains.

Try this strategy:

  1. Determine your budget
  2. Identify 3-5 models known for reliability in your preferred category
  3. Find examples that have depreciated into your price range
  4. Compare their mileages against typical lifespan expectations for that specific model

A real-world example: With $15,000, you might choose between:

  • A 3-year-old economy car with 40,000 miles
  • A 5-year-old midsize sedan with 70,000 miles
  • A 7-year-old luxury sedan with 90,000 miles

The midsize option often represents the best balance of remaining useful life versus price paid.

When to Choose Higher Mileage for Better Value

Sometimes the high-mileage option is actually the smartest choice. According to research from CarGurus, vehicles with 20-30% higher than average mileage typically sell for 15-25% less than their lower-mileage counterparts, yet often have only marginally higher maintenance costs.

Higher mileage makes particularly good sense when:

  • The vehicle is from a brand known for longevity: A Toyota with 130,000 miles may have another 100,000+ left
  • Major maintenance has just been performed: Timing belts, water pumps, etc.
  • The price discount exceeds likely repair costs: If you’re saving $3,000 but might need $1,000 in repairs
  • You’re a short-term owner: Planning to keep the car only 2-3 years
  • The vehicle history shows consistent care: Complete service records indicate a responsible previous owner

My personal preference? I’d rather buy a well-maintained 120,000-mile vehicle for $8,000 than a neglected 60,000-mile vehicle for $14,000. The difference in my pocket more than covers likely maintenance needs!

Long-Term Ownership Cost Considerations

The purchase price is just the beginning of the story. According to AAA’s 2023 Your Driving Costs study, the average cost to own and operate a vehicle goes far beyond the purchase price:

  • Depreciation: $3,100 annually (less on older vehicles)
  • Maintenance, repairs, tires: $1,650 annually (increases with vehicle age)
  • Fuel: $2,000 annually (varies widely by vehicle type)
  • Insurance: $1,750 annually
  • License, registration, taxes: $750 annually

Understanding these costs helps put mileage in proper context. For example, a higher-mileage vehicle might have:

  • Lower initial cost
  • Higher maintenance costs
  • Lower depreciation (it’s already depreciated)
  • Similar insurance and registration costs

A 2023 analysis by Consumer Reports found that buying a 5-year-old vehicle with 75,000-100,000 miles and keeping it for 5 years often resulted in the lowest total cost of ownership compared to newer or older options.

Remember this: good mileage for a used car isn’t just about what’s good when you buy it – it’s about what makes financial sense over your entire ownership period.

Conclusion

So, what have we learned about good mileage for a used car? Let’s bring it all together!

Finding the right used car isn’t about chasing the lowest possible mileage – it’s about finding the sweet spot where value, reliability, and condition meet. Remember how we debunked that old 100,000-mile myth? Modern vehicles are engineering marvels compared to cars from just 20 years ago!

Here’s your quick cheat sheet for good mileage benchmarks:

  • Economy cars: 75,000-125,000 miles often represents the best value
  • SUVs and crossovers: 90,000-150,000 miles typically hits the sweet spot
  • Trucks: 100,000-170,000 miles can be ideal territory for value
  • Luxury vehicles: 60,000-100,000 miles usually offers the best balance

But – and this is a BIG but – these numbers mean nothing without considering the full picture. A well-maintained Honda with 130,000 miles is often a smarter buy than a neglected BMW with 70,000 miles.

The used car market data from Kelley Blue Book’s 2023 Consumer Guide shows that buyers who prioritize comprehensive vehicle evaluation over simply seeking low mileage report 37% higher satisfaction with their purchases after one year of ownership.

My honest take? The odometer is just one piece of evidence in your used car investigation. The maintenance records, vehicle history report, pre-purchase inspection, and your own test drive impressions should all carry equal or greater weight in your decision.

As you head out to find your next vehicle, remember that good mileage for a used car isn’t a single magic number – it’s finding the right balance for your specific situation, budget, and the particular make and model you’re considering.

Trust your research, trust your mechanic, and sometimes, trust your gut. That slightly higher mileage car with immaculate service records? It might just be the best car you’ve ever owned.

FAQ Section

Is 100,000 miles too much for a used car?

Not at all! The 100,000-mile mark is an outdated benchmark from decades past. According to data from S&P Global Mobility, the average age of vehicles on U.S. roads reached a record 12.5 years in 2023, with many vehicles reaching 200,000+ miles.

Modern manufacturing techniques, better materials, and advanced lubricants have dramatically extended vehicle lifespans. A 2023 iSeeCars study found that 1.8% of all vehicles on the road had more than 200,000 miles, with some models regularly exceeding 250,000 miles.

The key factors that matter more than hitting the 100,000-mile mark include:

  • Consistent maintenance history
  • Driving conditions (highway vs. city)
  • Vehicle make and model reputation
  • How the vehicle has been stored and cared for

What’s more important: age or mileage?

Great question! The answer is… it depends on the specific situation. (Don’t you just love that kind of answer?)

Here’s the deal: both age and mileage matter, but in different ways. According to research from CarEdge.com, vehicles deteriorate from both use (mileage) and time (age), regardless of which one accumulates faster.

A 2022 study published in the International Journal of Automotive Technology found that:

  • Components like rubber hoses, gaskets, and seals deteriorate primarily with age
  • Drivetrain components like engines and transmissions wear primarily with use
  • Suspension components wear from both use and environmental exposure

The ideal used car balances age and mileage. The “sweet spot” is typically a vehicle with slightly below-average mileage for its age (10,000-12,000 miles per year instead of the average 13,500).

Extreme mismatches in either direction raise concerns:

  • Very low mileage for age suggests prolonged periods of sitting, which can cause issues
  • Very high mileage for age suggests hard use or primarily short trips

My recommendation? For most mainstream vehicles, prioritize condition and maintenance history first, then consider the age-mileage relationship as a secondary factor.

How many miles is too many for a used car?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but I can give you some useful guidelines based on vehicle type and brand reputation.

According to comprehensive data from RepairPal and Consumer Reports reliability surveys, these mileage thresholds typically represent the upper limits of what most buyers should consider:

  • Economy cars: 180,000-200,000 miles (Japanese brands), 150,000-170,000 miles (other brands)
  • Midsize sedans: 200,000-225,000 miles (top reliability brands), 160,000-180,000 miles (average brands)
  • SUVs/Crossovers: 200,000-250,000 miles (top reliability brands), 150,000-180,000 miles (average brands)
  • Trucks: 250,000-300,000 miles (top reliability brands), 180,000-220,000 miles (average brands)
  • Luxury vehicles: 150,000-180,000 miles (top reliability brands), 120,000-150,000 miles (average brands)

Even beyond these numbers, there are exceptions. A 2022 NYTimes article profiled multiple owners of vehicles exceeding 300,000 miles, with the common denominator being religious adherence to maintenance schedules.

What’s the sweet spot for used car mileage?

If you’re looking for the perfect balance of price, reliability, and remaining useful life, you’ll want to target what industry insiders call the “value sweet spot.”

According to analysis from Edmunds and TrueCar market data from 2023, the sweet spot for most used vehicles falls between:

  • 3-6 years old (when major depreciation has already occurred)
  • 40,000-80,000 miles (broken-in but not heavily worn)

This range typically offers:

  • 40-60% lower price compared to the same model new
  • Plenty of useful life remaining (typically 100,000+ more miles)
  • Modern safety features and technology
  • Potential remaining factory warranty on certified pre-owned vehicles

J.D. Power’s 2023 Vehicle Dependability Study showed that vehicles in this age and mileage range had only 15% more reported problems than brand new vehicles, while costing less than half as much.

For the absolute best value, I personally target used vehicles at roughly 60,000-75,000 miles from brands with strong reliability records. At this point, the vehicle has:

  • Depreciated substantially
  • Proven its reliability (major issues typically show up in the first 50,000 miles)
  • Still has approximately 60-70% of its useful life remaining

Should I avoid cars with over 150,000 miles?

Not necessarily! While 150,000+ mile vehicles deserve extra scrutiny, they can represent excellent value in specific circumstances.

According to a 2023 survey by AutoList of 10,000+ used car buyers, those who purchased vehicles with over 150,000 miles reported:

  • 41% paid cash for their vehicles (no financing)
  • 68% spent less than $8,000 total
  • 52% reported satisfaction with their purchase after one year
  • 37% experienced a major repair within the first year of ownership

The key to successfully buying a high-mileage vehicle is setting realistic expectations and budgeting appropriately. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau recommends budgeting approximately $1,500-2,500 per year for maintenance and repairs on vehicles over 150,000 miles.

High-mileage vehicles make the most sense when:

  • You’re on a tight budget and need reliable transportation
  • You have mechanical knowledge or access to affordable repairs
  • The vehicle has a documented maintenance history
  • The specific make/model is known for exceptional longevity
  • You’re purchasing from the original owner

My honest take? If your budget is limited, a well-maintained 160,000-mile Toyota Camry or Honda Accord is likely a better investment than a 120,000-mile vehicle from a less reliable manufacturer. Just be sure to get a thorough pre-purchase inspection and budget for more frequent repairs.

Remember – good mileage for a used car isn’t just about the number. It’s about finding the right vehicle for your specific situation, needs, and budget. Sometimes that might mean embracing higher miles to get a more reliable vehicle or better overall condition.

Share the Post

Picture of Paul Boland

Paul Boland

Paul is a 10-year automotive industry veteran passionate about cars, driving, and the future of mobility.
Bringing hands-on experience to every story, Paul covers the latest news and trends for real enthusiasts. Here is my bio for each blog also.

Read More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECOMMENDED

Bid For Autos © 2025. All Rights Reserved.